ISLAMABAD – Shocking Disclosure About Bureaucracy
Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) MNA Abdul Qadir Patel revealed that 22,000 Pakistani bureaucrats hold dual citizenship. This startling information emerged during a session of the National Assembly’s Standing Committee on Interior, chaired by Khurram Nawaz.
Key Topics Discussed at the Committee Meeting
The committee focused on two major issues:
- Legislation on dual citizenship and granting Pakistani passports to citizens of countries with dual citizenship agreements.
- Establishment of child courts to address cases of child abuse.
Dual Citizenship Among Bureaucrats: A Growing Concern
Patel’s Perspective on National Security Risks
Abdul Qadir Patel questioned the leniency extended to bureaucrats holding dual citizenship. He argued that while politicians face restrictions to avoid leaking state secrets, bureaucrats—who have access to classified files—are allowed dual citizenship without scrutiny.
Comparison of Politicians vs. Bureaucrats on Dual Citizenship
| Aspect | Politicians | Bureaucrats |
|---|---|---|
| Access to State Secrets | Limited or partial | Full access to classified files |
| Dual Citizenship Status | Generally discouraged | Allowed, despite national security risks |
| Scrutiny Level | High | Low |
Patel asked, “Why are politicians scrutinized, but bureaucrats are not? What secrets do politicians have? Everyone already knows everything about them.”
Approval of Child Court Bill
Amid debates on dual citizenship, the committee approved a significant bill to establish child courts across Pakistan. These courts aim to expedite child abuse cases and protect children’s rights effectively.
Demand for Transparency on Dual Citizenship
Call for Detailed Records
PPP MNA Agha Rafiullah called for comprehensive data on Pakistanis with dual citizenship. He also inquired about the number of individuals who have renounced Pakistani citizenship, citing a recent case where a dual citizen was appointed to a prominent position.
Summary of Rafiullah’s Concerns
| Issue Raised | Details |
|---|---|
| Total dual citizenship holders | 22,000 bureaucrats |
| Number of renouncers | Data requested |
| Allegations | Appointment of a dual citizen to a key position last year |
Controversy Over Legislation for Renouncers
Opposition to Granting Passports
PPP MNA Nabeel Gabol criticized the proposal to grant Pakistani passports to individuals who have renounced their citizenship. He argued that renouncing Pakistani nationality is disrespectful to the country and should not be rewarded.
Diverging Views Within the Committee
| Party | Position on Dual Citizenship |
|---|---|
| PPP (Gabol’s View) | Opposes granting passports to renouncers; sees it as a national insult |
| PML-N | Supports legislation, citing that renouncing citizenship is not disrespectful |
| PTI | Demands further clarification and briefing from relevant authorities |
Next Steps: Summoning Key Officials
The Standing Committee has decided to summon officials from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the Establishment Division for further deliberations.
Conclusion: A Debate on National Security and Accountability
The issue of dual citizenship among Pakistani bureaucrats raises questions about transparency and security. The next committee meeting is expected to provide clarity on this sensitive matter, shaping the future of Pakistan’s dual citizenship policies.
